94
Robert Parker - Wine Advocate
The 2005 Melbury offers lovely aromas of cedar, creme
de cassis, licorice, and smoked/roasted herbs as well as good underlying
acidity, full-bodied power, and stunning concentration, but also
unmistakable elegance and harmony. While these are all big wines,
there is an attractive European tannic profile to the 2005 Melbury.
Although accessible now, 3-5 years of bottle age will be beneficial,
and it should improve for 20-25 years. Drink '11 - '36. |
90
Wine Spectator
Well-centered, showing ripe, spicy plum, black cherry
and currant flavors, with firm, integrated tannins and good length,
tightening up on the finish.
Best from '11 through '17. |